The World’s 19 Dreamiest Private Island Hotels, From the Maldives to Wisconsin

Walk on powdery white sand, swim in azure water, and gaze at star-studded skies at these intimate escapes.
Aerial view of large houses on coast, with pool and palm trees and surrounded by sea

Soneva Fushi, from Six Senses founders Sonu Shivdasani and Eva Malmström, first opened in 1995.

Courtesy of Soneva Fushi

In this Article

This article was originally published in 2025 and most recently updated on November 19, 2026, with current information.

When it comes to beach vacations, exclusivity is the ultimate luxury, and that’s why private island resorts are so appealing: Imagine waking up steps from an empty beach with few to no other travelers, the natural soundtrack of birds chirping and waves crashing playing outside.

For Afar’s latest Hotels We Love series, we’re focusing on the best private island resorts the world has to offer. While we chose hotels that offer sumptuous accommodations and superlative service, we also prioritized the ones that operate sustainably to preserve the cultures and the settings from which they and their guests benefit. Read on to learn more about these 19 sublime private island resorts around the world—some far flung, others just a short flight from home.

United States

Little Palm Island Resort & Spa: Florida

Guest room at Little Palm Island Resort & Spa, with white clawfoot tub outdoors

Little Palm Island Resort & Spa

Photo by Sammy Todd Dyess Photography

Location: Florida Keys

Why we love it: An adults-only private island escape—no passport required

Rate: From $2,392

Positioned 28 miles east of Key West, the four-acre Little Palm Island is the only adults-only private island resort in the United States. The Relais & Châteaux resort is ideal for couples (there’s even a Romance Concierge). The 30 thatched-roof bungalow suites, each with private outdoor showers and verandas and no televisions, are hidden in tropical foliage.

Aside from relaxing on the secluded beach, many guests spend time in SpaTerre, which offers Balinese and Thai treatments, or on the provided kayaks and paddleboards. Diving, fishing, and sailing excursions are also available. —Devorah Lev-Tov

Stout’s Island Lodge: Wisconsin

Location: Red Cedar Lake, Wisconsin

Why we love it: Historic lodge dating back more than a century, even smaller satellite islands for additional privacy, summer camp vibes

Rates: From $146

If you assume that all the best private islands are in the tropics, think again: The historic Stout’s Island Lodge sits in the middle of Wisconsin’s Red Cedar Lake, surrounded by thick forests and expansive waters filled with bluegill, bass, pike, and walleye.

The original main lodge was built back in 1903 for Chicago businessman Frank Stout and modeled after the Adirondack Great Camps frequented by Vanderbilts and Rockefellers in the late 1800s. Stout and his family used it as a summer retreat for many years, and almost a century later, it was transformed into a luxury resort.

The rustic-chic guest rooms and cabins each have their own unique decor: Some include log beds and stone fireplaces; others have botanical wallpapers and homey quilts. Those looking for even more privacy can rent the three-acre Van Reed Island on Red Cedar Lake. The island has a four-bedroom home with wraparound decks and a rentable pontoon boat.

Caribbean/Central America

Cayo Espanto: Belize

Distant view of small, green island surrounded by shallow waters

Cayo Espanto

Courtesy of Cayo Espanto

Location: Cayo Espanto, Belize

Why we love it: A private island paradise for divers and fishing enthusiasts

Rates: From $2,295 (all-inclusive)

About three miles off the coast from San Pedro, Cayo Espanto is an alluring option for Belize-bound travelers. The resort has an all-inclusive model for its seven one-bedroom villas and two two-bedroom villas, which all have private pools and docks except for one overwater bungalow.

Each villa is assigned a butler who is at the ready for any requests, including meals. (There are no set menus; guests work with the chef to tailor their meals.) Belize is known for its diving and fishing, and Cayo Espanto has its own dive boats, dive masters, and fishing guides who arrange excursions. —DLT

COMO Parrot Cay: Turks and Caicos

Distant view of large swimming pool and hotel among palm trees, with beach and palm trees in foreground

COMO Parrot Cay is about a half hour by boat from Providenciales.

Courtesy of COMO Parrot Cay

Location: Turks and Caicos

Why we love it: An A-list escape where wellness takes center stage

Loyalty program: Comoclub

Rates: From $1,900

A 35-minute boat ride off the coast of Providenciales takes you to a 1,000-acre piece of paradise: COMO Parrot Cay. This Turks and Caicos resort is a favorite hideaway for bold-faced names seeking a wellness-inspired stay. (Keep an eye out for Keith Richards, Christie Brinkley, and Donna Karan—who all own private homes here.)

The 61 accommodations embrace a beachy aesthetic with white shiplap walls, pickled wood ceilings, driftwood tables, and flowy curtains everywhere you look. For the ultimate indulgence, splurge on a beach house, villa, or estate, all of which come with butler service.

Sustainability is at the heart of COMO Parrot Cay. Nearly 85 percent of the island is a protected habitat for native wildlife, while the resort’s coconut grove and banana farm provide fresh produce for its kitchens.

Wellness is woven into every aspect of the experience, from COMO Shambhala spa therapies and sunrise beach meditations to Ayurvedic consultations and nourishing, health-focused cuisine. Guests spend their days snorkeling along the reefs, paddling through mangroves, or simply sinking into island time with a fresh coconut in hand. —LBB

Islas Secas: Panama

Lounge chair on wood deck next to plunge pool facing Pacific Ocean

Some accommodations at Islas Secas have plunge pools that face the Pacific Ocean.

Courtesy of Islas Secas

Location: Islas Secas archipelago, Panama

Why we love it: A luxurious castaway experience run on solar power

Rates: From $3,500 (all-inclusive)

The remote Panama archipelago of Islas Secas is a preserve of 14 protected volcanic islands 20 miles off the country’s Pacific coast. With 750 species of fish, 124 bird species, and 128 species of plants, this biodiversity hot spot is also home to the all-inclusive Islas Secas resort, composed of a handful of casitas—some tented—with outdoor plunge pools or soaking tubs.

At Islas Secas, conservation is a key pillar, and 100 percent of the property’s power is solar generated, all food waste is composted, and all wastewater is used for irrigation. Guests keep busy with nature-focused activities like seasonal whale watching, diving, and hiking. —DLT

Jumby Bay Island: Antigua

White guest room with blue carpeting and sliding glass doors to patio with sea-facing view

Gaze out at the turquoise Caribbean from your room at Jumby Bay Island.

Courtesy of Jumby Bay Island

Location: Jumby Bay Island, Antigua, Antigua & Barbuda

Why we love it: A car-free private island with empty beaches

Rated: From $2,850 (all-inclusive)

Jumby Bay Island is a private island two miles off mainland Antigua. Ringed with coral reefs, the 300-acre private isle, managed by Oetker Collection, has two white-powder beaches and three sparkling pools. There are no cars; instead, most people get around on foot or via winding paths on bikes provided by the resort. The 40 suites and 36 villas and private residences, in white and blue, are secluded retreats surrounded by tropical foliage.

Guests can sail on the resort’s private yacht or use the extensive water sports equipment, which ranges from water skis to windsurfers. There are four restaurants, a kids club, and a spa with five ocean-view treatment suites, while the recently opened the Hut, Little Jumby, is its own private island beach club and restaurant a short ferry ride away.

Seventy percent of the island’s energy is provided by solar energy, and the island acts as a sanctuary for endangered hawksbill sea turtles. From June to November, a team monitors and records nesting activities, tagging each turtle to track their progress. —DLT

Necker Island: British Virgin Islands

A curving, sea-facing infinity pool at Necker Island

Necker Island

Courtesy of Necker Island

Location: Necker Island, North Sound of British Virgin Islands

Why we love it: Commune with nature and wildlife between beach excursions and padel matches

Rates: From $5,272 per night (all inclusive)

Set on 74 acres of white-sand beaches and green landscapes, Necker Island is part of Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Limited Edition collection. The private island’s accommodations include the Great House, which has 11 bedrooms and one bunk-bedroom ideal for kids, and 10 Balinese-style houses scattered across the island. Necker Island can be booked for exclusive use, while small-group and individual stays are allowed on various weeks throughout the year.

Guests have access to the island’s four freshwater infinity pools, hot tubs, and tennis, pickleball, and padel courts, along with a wide variety of water sports. They share the island with an abundance of wildlife, including flamingos, lemurs, giant tortoises, and 52 bird species—whose habitats the resort helps to conserve. Much of Necker Island’s energy also relies on its three giant wind turbines and solar farm. —DLT

Peter Island Resort: British Virgin Islands

Shallow outdoor oval pool, with several short palm trees, empty brown lounge chairs, and a green hill beyond it

One way to enjoy the water at Peter Island Resort

Courtesy of Peter Island Resort

Location: British Virgin Islands

Why we love it: A Caribbean icon

Rates: From $1,067

Peter Island, the largest private island resort in the British Virgin Islands, spans 1,800 wild acres with dramatic hiking trails and five powdery white-sand beaches. Most of the 52 accommodations are steps from the sand, and eight have private outdoor hot tubs. The crowning glory is the Falcon’s Nest, a six-bedroom estate that sits atop a hill and comes with 360-degree ocean views, an infinity pool, and endless indoor-outdoor living spaces.

Guests can spend their days indulging in wellness treatments at the 10,000-square-foot spa or dining on surf and turf at the Drake Steakhouse. This island has access to some of the best sailing in the Caribbean, and the Yacht Club’s revamped marina welcomes vessels up to 200 feet long. Sustainability is woven into the island’s DNA. Two wind turbines provide up to 75 percent of its energy, while an on-island desalination plant provides the resort with drinking water. Locally sourced materials were used to construct the beachfront spaces, and an innovative food-waste reduction program partners with an organic farm on nearby Tortola. —LBB

Europe

Isle of Eriska: Scotland

Exterior of a castle, with a small marshy pond with lily pads in the foreground

Eriska House, Isle of Eriska’s main building, dates to 1884.

Courtesy of Isle of Eriska

Location: Loch Creran, Scotland

Why we love it: Wildlife including roe deer and otters; whiskey and gin tasting; many outdoor activities

Loyalty program: The Club by SLH (Small Luxury Hotels of the World)

Rates: From $440

On the Isle of Eriska, a 365-acre private island with a hotel and spa two and a half hours northwest of Glasgow, you’re a 30-minute drive from the seaside town of Oban; yet the area feels much more remote, surrounded by the wild beauty of Scottish lakes and mountains with abundant wildlife, including roe deer, seals, otters, golden eagles, and badgers. Step into a pair of Wellingtons (staff keep them by the front door), and explore the grounds on foot, or linger over the whiskey menu in the main house.

The guest rooms and suites are delightfully mismatched, each drawing on the unique architecture of the space, and other accommodation options suit groups of different sizes, including spa and garden cottages hidden in the historic stables and the six-person Arnott’s House. While on the property, you can take part in such activities as archery, axe throwing, falconry, beekeeping, fishing, golfing, and much more.

Related: Scotland’s Cheese Trail Is the Farmhouse Food Adventure You Didn’t Know You Needed

JW Marriott Venice Resort & Spa

The orange-hued facade of JW Mariott Venice Resort & Spa, with a person in a small boat on the water in foreground and a couple on the dock

The JW Marriott Venice Resort & Spa

Courtesy of JW Marriott

Location: Venice, Italy

Why we love it: A quiet respite away from Venice’s tourist crowds

Loyalty program: Marriott Bonvoy

Rates: From $385

The seasonal JW Marriott Venice Resort & Spa sits on its own 40-acre private island, Isola delle Rose, which has an olive grove and a fruit orchard and is a short boat ride from Piazza San Marco. Its 266 guest rooms are divided between JW Rooms in the main building and JW Retreats, which offer more privacy amid private gardens with plunge pools.

Guests can try their hand at Italian specialties at the on-site cooking school that uses produce from the resort’s garden, and there are several dining options, including a pizzeria and a rooftop restaurant. The JW Spa has a view of the lagoon and eight treatment rooms, a sauna and a bio sauna, a hammam, and a heated indoor pool. —DLT

Related: Exploring Venice as a Wheelchair User Showed Me a Side of the City Most Tourists Never See

Asia

The Nautilus Maldives

Location: Thiladhoo Island, Baa Atoll, Maldives

Why we love it: Overwater spa with glass-bottomed treatment rooms, located in a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve

Rates: From $2,478
Sunset over the indian ocean, with a pool bar with palm trees in the foreground

You’ll watch the sun melt into the Indian Ocean every night from your perch at the Nautilus Maldives

Photo courtesy the Nautilus Maldives

The Indian Ocean archipelago is beloved for its overwater bungalow options. At the Nautilus Maldives, 26 beach and ocean houses share tiny, private Thiladhoo Island in the Baa Atoll, a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve known for its whale sharks and manta rays. The room rate includes the services of a private butler, and there’s a 24-hour overwater spa with glass-bottomed treatment pavilions.

Activities are designed to feel spontaneous and luxurious, meaning you might find yourself on a last-minute yacht adventure around the islands, watching a screened movie under the stars, or listening to live music and eating the freshest grilled seafood by a fire. For the ultimate experience, book the island’s three-bedroom mansion with a private pool that’s ideal for families.

Soneva Fushi Maldives

Distant aerial view of an elevated wooden structure with a long winding staircase leading up to it among palm trees at sunset

Soneva Fushi

Courtesy of Soneva Fushi

Location: Baa Atoll, Maldives

Why we love it: A trailblazer for sustainability in the Maldives

Rates: From $1,824

The moment guests arrive at Soneva Fushi in the Maldives, staff whisk away guests’ shoes and hand over a bicycle: This is all about slow, sustainable, barefoot luxury. When Six Senses founders Sonu Shivdasani and Eva Malmström opened Soneva Fushi in 1995, they were ahead of the curve—proving that luxury and eco-sensitivity can go hand in hand. They later sold the Six Senses brand but held on to this pioneering property.

Villas embrace indoor-outdoor living, with retractable roofs, open-air bathrooms, and handcrafted furnishings made from reclaimed materials. The resort recycles 90 percent of its waste, leads conservation projects like coral restoration, and is home to a glassblowing studio, where discarded bottles are repurposed into art.

Experiences at Soneva Fushi range from dining in the treetops on a zip-line adventure to snorkeling with manta rays. The Soneva Soul wellness center offers holistic treatments, while the Den—the largest kids club in the Maldives, which has another branch at along with sister resort Soneva Jani—immerses younger travelers in creativity and exploration. —LBB

Song Saa Private Island: Cambodia

Distant aerial view of two small islands covered in green foliage, surrounded by Gulf of Thailand, and connected by a footbridge

Song Saa Private Island

Courtesy of Song Saa Island

Location: Koh Rong Archipelago, Cambodia

Why we love it: A luxe island escape where sustainability takes center stage

Rates: From $1,024

Since opening in 2012 in the Koh Rong Archipelago off the coast of Sihanoukville, Cambodia’s Song Saa Private Island has been raising the bar for sustainable luxury, and even became a B Corp company in 2023. The resort is spread across two tiny islands linked by a footbridge over the country’s first marine reserve, developed to safeguard turtles, seahorses, and tropical fish. The 24 villas are built with reclaimed timber from old fishing boats and have canopy beds, driftwood furniture, sunken bathtubs, and private infinity pools.

Through the Song Saa Foundation, guests can visit the nearby village of Prek Svay, deliver medical supplies to the archipelago’s smaller villages, or scuba dive with marine scientists. After dark, the sea lights up with bioluminescent plankton, best experienced on a guided night swim. For wellness seekers, the island’s spa with no walls has open-air sanctuaries where therapies are guided by Buddhist principles of stillness, healing, and blessings. And when it’s time to leave? A speedboat whisks you back to Sihanoukville, but part of you will want to stay marooned forever. —LBB

Africa

andBeyond Mnemba Island: Zanzibar

One person on white-sand beach with thatch-roofed seating area at right

As a private isle, andBeyond Mnemba Island offers the ultimate seclusion.

Courtesy of andBeyond Mnemba Island

Location: Mnemba Island, Zanzibar, Tanzania

Why we love it: A wild island in the culture-rich Zanzibar archipelago

Loyalty program: I Prefer (Preferred Hotels and Resorts)

Rates: From $2,215 per person (all-inclusive)

On an island off the coast of northeast Zanzibar, andBeyond Mnemba Island Lodge is the idyllic antidote to the beach crowds on the nearby Zanzibar island. Twelve thatch-roofed bandas (1,300-square-foot guest suites) fan out on the beachfront from the central lodge. The Wellness Banda has two treatment rooms and a platform for yoga and sound baths; the Dive Center offers experiences such as clear-bottomed kayaking and pedal boarding (stand-up paddleboarding meets an elliptical machine).

The lodge also houses the Discovery Centre, where guests can explore the initiatives of Oceans Without Borders, a marine conservation group managed by andBeyond and its community development partner, Wild Impact. Projects include a coral nursery, an artificial coral reef restoration project, and a sanctuary for two antelope species, the Aders’ duiker and the suni antelope (tiny antelope weighing about 10 pounds). —DLT

Miavana by Time+Tide: Madagascar

Aerial view of a woman in a white float in the middle of a turquoise ocean, peacefully reading a book

At Miavana by Time + Tide, this could be you floating peacefully in the Indian Ocean.

Photo by Dylane Cabano

Location: Madagascar

Why we love it: Spacious villas, lemur treks, a museum-like Cabinet of Curiosities

Rates: From $3,700 per person (all-inclusive)

Miavana, a private island hotel off the northeast coast of Madagascar, promises all the relaxing benefits of an unhurried island paradise, but with lots of adventure options that will make you feel as if you’re on safari: nature treks to see the island’s resident crowned lemurs, bird-watching by boat, and snorkeling or diving among unspoiled coral reefs.

The “smallest” of the 13 villas sprawls over more than 6,600 square feet, so consider these homes away from home. You don’t want to miss the museum-quality Cabinet de Curiosities in the main public space, which includes a gorgeous butterfly collection, an antique ship’s wheel, and the skeletons of two extinct Madagascan species, the pygmy hippo and the elephant bird.

North Island: Seychelles

Open-air room at North Island with a large wood veranda facing ocean

North Island, a Luxury Collection Resort

Courtesy of Andrew Howard Photo/North Island

Location: Seychelles

Why we love it: Luxury and conservation in one of the world’s most remote settings

Rates: From $10,500 (all-inclusive)

North Island is more than just a private-island escape—it’s a restoration success story. The Noah’s Ark Conservation Project transformed a once-abandoned coconut plantation into a sanctuary for endangered species, from rare Seychelles magpie robins to nesting green and hawksbill turtles. Be sure to say hi to the island’s most celebrated resident: Brutus, an Aldabra giant tortoise believed to be more than 160 years old. Guests are invited to join the island’s conservation efforts, whether it’s helping plant native trees or joining rangers on sunrise turtle patrols.

But sustainability doesn’t mean sacrifice. The 11 villas are sprawling 5,000-square-foot beachfront hideaways built from locally sourced materials and designed for open-air living, with private pools, shaded terraces, and butlers at the ready. When it comes to food, tuck into Creole-inspired dishes at the Piazza or wood-fired pizza at Sunset Bar, or ask for a meal to be served anywhere on the property, whether at a lantern-lit table on the beach or in the privacy of your villa. —LBB

Oceania

The Brando: French Polynesia

Narrow pool next to wood deck with short row of empty lounge chairs and umbrella, plus palm trees at left

The Brando was the world’s first resort to achieve LEED Platinum certification.

Courtesy of the Brando

Location: Tetiʻaroa Atoll, French Polynesia

Why we love it: Marlon Brando’s private island, with serious sustainability credentials

Rates: From $3,250

Encompassing 35 private villas on the Motu Onetahi coast of French Polynesian island Tetiʻaroa, leased by the estate of actor Marlon Brando, the Brando is one of the most luxurious places to stay in the South Pacific. It also has some serious sustainability cred. The LEED Platinum–certified resort, the world’s first, is constantly working to minimize its carbon footprint: for example, by implementing an air-conditioning system that draws from cool ocean water, on-site composting, and a desalination plant that produces fresh water for the resort.

A partnership with nonprofit group Tetiaroa Society connects guests with naturalists and researchers who lead snorkeling and scuba outings and guided nature walks. Travelers interested in Polynesian culture may want to test the resort’s traditional outrigger canoe on a trip to one of the surrounding private islets that share an atoll with the Brando. All villas at this all-inclusive resort have their own private pool and direct beach access. The spa offers a range of healing modalities, including a traditional Polynesian taurumi massage.

Kokomo Private Island: Fiji

Wood deck at villa, with two lounge chairs under a white umbrella facing the South Pacific

Kokomo Private Island’s villas all have views of the South Pacific.

Photo by Maria Louw Photography

Location: Kokomo, Kadavu Islands, Fiji

Why we love it: A private island experience for all ages, with two beaches

Rates: From $2,900

South of the Fijian mainland, on 140 acres, Kokomo Private Island combines traditional Fijian design (thatched roofs) with contemporary touches (sleek tiled plunge pools). The property has 21 villas, each with its own infinity pool, all scattered far from each other along the island’s two beaches. Five hilltop Grand Residences offer uninterrupted views of the South Pacific. Guests of all ages enjoy activities such as diving, fishing, kayaking, and snorkeling.

For younger guests, there’s a kids club with activities like treasure hunts and mangrove planting, while for adults, the Yaukuve Spa Sanctuary has five treatment rooms and a wet and dry hammam. The resort is committed to preserving the island via regenerative and sustainable programs ranging from coral restoration and composting to desalination plants, which create fresh water for the pools and gardens and sea salt for the kitchen. The island is also home to a five-and-a-half-acre organic farm with free-range chickens that provide the island’s eggs, and beehives that generate the resort’s honey. —DLT

Lizard Island: Australia

Location: Queensland, Australia

Why we love it: Access to the Great Barrier Reef, plus an architecturally significant house

Rates: From $1,430

The northernmost island resort of Australia’s Great Barrier Reef, Lizard Island Resort is redefining barefoot luxury in the region. It’s surrounded by a national park, with a series of rooms, villas, and suites set within strolling distance of the beach and the reef beyond. Experiences include glass-bottom sea kayaking, guided snorkeling with the help of a motorized sea scooter, or fishing for mahi-mahi, tuna, and marlin off the outer reef.

Small groups can book the House, a three-story, three-bedroom residence on a secluded peninsula with a floor plan meant to evoke a stingray—complete with gill-shaped windows to let in the breeze. Made of rugged concrete, the climate-resilient space is designed to withstand cyclonic winds, and its interiors are filled with sumptuous detailing using rosewood timber, copper, and emerald quartzite.

Related: There’s a New Way to Experience the Great Barrier Reef—and Give Back While You’re There

Nicholas DeRenzo, Annie Fitzsimmons, and Sophie Friedman contributed to the reporting of this story.

Laura Begley Bloom is a travel expert and content strategist who contributes to a wide range of magazines and websites and appears regularly on television outlets ranging from the Weather Channel to CNN. Journalism is part of Laura’s heritage: Her great great grandfather was a Civil War correspondent for the Chicago Tribune.
FROM OUR PARTNERS
Sign up for our newsletter
Join more than a million of the world’s best travelers. Subscribe to the Daily Wander newsletter.
MORE FROM AFAR