5620 Macdonald Avenue
Photo courtesy of Roostica
Roostica Even in a town famous for seafood, sometimes pizza just sounds too good to pass up. On Stock Island, a bohemian neighborhood of Key West, Roostica, a wood-fired-pizza joint, serves a well-rounded menu of specialty pies, salads, appetizers, and "Italian soul food" (which includes staples like chicken parm, veal marsala, and linguine with clam sauce). The covered patio is strung with twinkling lights and hanging lanterns, making it a nice spot for dinner after a day at the beach.