This pizzeria is among the city’s best, even though it’s a few blocks from Little Italy. Tucked away from the Main on Rue Maguire, this dark-wood and blackboard-paint decorated spot feels like a nook away from the bustle. It’s a great place for two or for medium groups, with fun high tables in the front. The menu features old timey American classics like oysters on the half shell and cocktails they would have served in speakeasies in addition to the variety of pizzas. There’s a daily pizza variation written on the sandwich board outside, but out of the regulars, one of the most beloved is the meatball and three-cheese pie.