Stroll a rain-forested path—or hire a brightly painted rowboat and guide—to reach this open-air watering hole. It anchors a rudimentary botanical garden up the Indian River, one of the most famous Pirates of the Caribbean film locations. Try the Dynamite Punch, a stiff concoction allegedly containing 44 fruits. "One cup is good, two is better, but for three, we call 9-1-1," cautions Guide James "Bond" Henry. Open 7 a.m.–7 p.m. daily, reserve ahead for lunch.