"Classic Caribbean" best describes this idyllic hideaway in the heart of historic Cockburn Town. The charming clapboard house was first constructed as a home for Methodist clergy. Today, they might be baffled by the menu at the inn's restaurant as it has become a local favorite thanks to its Thai and other Asian dishes. Choose from curries made with fish and shrimp straight from the sea. If you want to give your taste buds a break from all the spices, order the key lime pie for dessert.