E Tittlemouse & Co
246 Bay Street
Score Designer ThreadsSlightly hidden downtown, this small consignment shop is a locals’ favorite in the NYC metro area. Score designer duds, like a Kate Spade dress, Prada purse, or Yves St. Laurent suit, usually for less than $100.
Sometimes the clothing is still new with tags, and the owners hand-select items, ensuring the inventory is always top notch. You’ll even find accessories, jewelry—and specialty soaps (which are not secondhand, of course).