The 2-year-old Scrub Island Resort has one of the closest marinas to the North Drop, a famous fishing spot for blue marlin. Half- and full- day fishing charters include a boat, a guide, and equipment. Guests who land a tuna or a marlin can bring it back to the resort and the chef will prepare their catch for dinner.
Rooms from $625. (877) 890-7444. This appeared in the November/December 2012 issue.