Post display cropped open uri20121230 5657 1rczx8g?1438706068

The best pie in Brooklyn

From Black Bottom Oatmeal to the traditional Apple pie, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is a place your inner food critic will never forget.

A sliver of a store with a few communal tables, the shop has only one oven and plenty of demand, and they sell pie by the slice. It's cash only and the steep price of a pie slice shouldn't set you back because it truly is THAT good (plus they bake everything from scratch, even the crust). The Black Bottom Oatmeal, which is chocolate crunch heaven, is a good bet, but they also have some exotic combinations like Salted Caramel Apple and Lemon Chess.

Large arrow right
read moreread less>
Thumb 895306103d21a6cbc78a7af6c313ca98
by Charu Suri
AFAR Ambassador

AFAR Ambassadors are in-the-know bloggers who have a passion for experiential travel.

I've been here
No one has been here. Be the first.
Does this place need a closer look by our editors? Let us know.