We wandered Anguilla in our car and found a winner at Scilly Cay (pronounced "key").
This is where the fisherman come in with their catch - we saw bag loads of huge lobster pulled out of boats.
Falcon's Nest is also a locals place - we observed what they were ordering and sure enough they did not steer us wrong.
The fried fish bits with the hot sauce, a little bit of mustard and a Carib were so delicious. *mouth watering*
This is certainly a no frills place and may be slightly intimidating to those "resort only" folk. but seriously ....go mingle with the locals here - they know what they're about!